About Assisted LivingAssisted living facilities offer housing and care for active seniors who may need support with activities of daily living, like bathing, dressing, and medication management.Complete guide to assisted livingBest of 2026 Assisted Living Winners
About Memory CareMemory care facilities provide housing, care, and therapies for seniors who have Alzheimer’s disease or other forms of dementia in an environment designed to reduce confusion and prevent wandering. Complete guide to memory careBest of 2026 Memory Care Winners
About Independent LivingIndependent living facilities offer convenient, hassle-free living in a social environment for seniors who are active, healthy, and able to live on their own.Complete guide to independent livingBest of 2026 Independent Living Winners
About Senior LivingSenior living is a term used to describe various housing and care options for older adults from maintenance-free, 55+ facilities for active seniors, to secure, fully staffed facilities for seniors with Alzheimer's or dementia. Complete guide to senior livingFind senior living facilities near you
About Nursing HomesNursing homes provide short-and long-term care for seniors who have physical or mental health conditions that require 24-hour nursing and personal care.Complete guide to Nursing Homes
About Senior ApartmentsSenior apartments offer accessible living for seniors who are generally active, healthy, and able to live on their own.Complete guide to Senior Apartments
About Care HomesResidential care homes are shared neighborhood homes for seniors who need a live-in caregiver to assist with activities of daily living, like dressing and bathing.Complete guide to care homes
Veteran ResourcesVA benefits for long-term care, such as Aid and Attendance benefits, can help eligible veterans and their surviving spouses pay for senior care.Guide to VA benefits for long-term care
Senior Living Awards
Add Review
(866) 388-7494
Talk to a local advisor for FREE
VERIFIED PARTNER

The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

9974 Federalist Dr, Fishers, IN 46037

For pricing & availability:
(866) 374-4058
8.9
Review score
24 reviews
Add review
8.9
Review score
24 reviews
  • 5 star
    63%
  • 4 star
    25%
  • 3 star
    4%
  • 2 star
    4%
  • 1 star
    4%
See all reviews
7.4
Review score
141 reviews
14 facilities
SaveShare
The Reserve at Hamilton Trace
SaveShare
The Reserve at Hamilton Trace aerial view of community
10 photos
The Reserve at Hamilton Trace in google map
street view of The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

Anonymous

Resident/client

5.0 out of 5 stars

The Right Place for Me

Dining is excellent. Free continental breakfast M-Sat. Activities are excellent. Lots to do or not do at your pleasure. Staff members are excellent. Always friendly and willing to help.

Read all reviews

The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

Comfortably situated on the outer edge of the Indianapolis suburbs, The Reserve at Hamilton Trace offers peaceful natural surroundings and access to a variety of urban conveniences. A place where residents can live the good life, The Reserve offers a number of lifestyle options, including independent living, assisted living, rehabilitation, and memory care. Surrounded by a beautifully landscaped campus and bordered by the Sand Creek Natural Area, the community provides opportunities to enjoy time with friends, and space to appreciate private moments.

The Reserve takes a customized approach to care, whether it be assisting with activities of daily living or providing memory care residents with cognitively stimulating activities. Caregivers work with each resident to create a care plan that addresses their individual needs and interests. The Reserve serves three family-style meals each day to help ensure that everyone receives the nutrients they need to thrive.

Residents can maintain their health and enjoy the serene outdoor settings with the on-site walking paths, sunny patios, and exercise classes, or venture off-site for even more excitement. The Reserve is just 30 minutes from the bustling center of Indianapolis and is near a variety of fun attractions in the Fishers area. The Geist Reservoir offers a...

Senior living options offered

  • Assisted Living
  • Independent Living

The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

Pricing

Total monthly costs depend on room type, select services, and the level of care needed

Base fees by care type

  • Request pricing
    Contact a local advisor
  • Unlocked
    Get a quote from your local advisor

*Prices quoted are monthly rental charges and are provided by the communities themselves. Actual prices may differ due to one-time fees, timing and care services required. Speak with your Senior Living Advisor to learn more.

Reviews

for The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

8.9 out of 10
Review Score24 reviewsWrite a review
Overall Experience
4.3
Cleanliness
4.2
Friendliness
4.3
Care Services
3.9
Staff
4.5
Meals & Dining
4.2
Activities
3.9
Value for Cost
4.1

A Place for Mom has scored The Reserve at Hamilton Trace with 8.9 out of 10 using our proprietary review score based on 3 reviews in the last 2 years. Over all time, The Reserve at Hamilton Trace has 24 reviews with an average "overall experience" of 4.3 out of 5.

Filters

1-20 of 24 reviews

Last Updated: 9/29/25

Overall Experience
Date Submitted
Reviewer
Care Received
Verified Review

A Place For Mom has verified the person writing the review and their connection to the community.

Anonymous

Independent Living

Resident/client

September 29, 2025

5.0 out of 5 stars
Verified Review

The Right Place for Me

Dining is excellent. Free continental breakfast M-Sat. Activities are excellent. Lots to do or not do at your pleasure. Staff members are excellent. Always friendly and willing to help.

Anonymous

Independent Living

Family/friend

September 19, 2025

5.0 out of 5 stars
Verified Review

Great family transition

All has been great so far. Especially staff very helpful with move in and transition Responds quickly with a questions and assistance.

Anonymous

Assisted Living

Family/friend

March 14, 2025

5.0 out of 5 stars
Verified Review
Cleanliness
4.0
Friendliness
5.0
Value for Cost
5.0
Care Services
5.0
Activities
4.0
Staff
5.0
Meals & Dining
5.0

Review for The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

Most important thing is to get on the waitlist, understand your position on the waitlist and the waitlist priority policy. Close to family, great value, friendly staff.

anonymous

Assisted Living

Family/friend

December 6, 2022

5.0 out of 5 stars
Verified Review
Cleanliness
5.0
Friendliness
5.0
Value for Cost
5.0
Care Services
5.0
Activities
5.0
Staff
5.0
Meals & Dining
5.0

A nice friendly community

Our loved one is on the assisted living side and so far the experience with The Reserve at Hamilton Trace has been great. All of the activities seem to keep our loved one busy, and the meals are great. It is a really nice environment and it is very clean. The staff have great follow up and communication. Based on our experience so far we would recommend them to other families.

Chris k

Assisted Living

Family/friend

June 13, 2022

2.0 out of 5 stars
Cleanliness
4.0
Friendliness
4.0
Value for Cost
2.0
Care Services
2.0
Staff
3.0
Meals & Dining
1.0

Tenants don’t seem too important

This is a very expensive place yet the food is barely edible. We’ve been very frustrated as nothing has changed for quite some time. Also, for the elderly watching tv may be a big part of their day yet this place changed the service where they get less channels. It’s so sad because this facility is VERY expensive. One would think the food would be edible and cable service would be the best! We ask for changes but it’s like they dont care.

Julie C

Independent Living

Family/friend

October 18, 2021

5.0 out of 5 stars
Verified Review
Cleanliness
3.0
Friendliness
5.0
Value for Cost
3.5
Activities
4.0
Meals & Dining
5.0

Home at The Reserve

We chose The Reserve because they offered a cottage which was a bigger space for them. So far things have been great, my parents love how quiet and safe the community is. My dad really enjoys walking and they have a nice gazebo where we can all sit and talk. They no longer have house keeping in their cottages because of the staffing shortages, but they are working on it. Overall, I would recommend to others looking.

anonymous

Assisted Living

Family/friend

September 27, 2021

4.5 out of 5 stars
Verified Review
Cleanliness
5.0

Our tour experience

Our family had an in person tour, and the community was very very clean. However we did not choose the community because we did not really get a feeling that the encouraged the residents to get our of their rooms and be active. Another facility we toured was encouraging them, and interacting with the residents which was so good to see. The feeling with got with The Reserve is that if you are someone who really does not want to interact with anyone and just want to be alone, this would be the place for you.

Mark

Assisted Living

Family/friend

August 20, 2021

5.0 out of 5 stars
Verified Review
Cleanliness
5.0
Friendliness
5.0
Value for Cost
5.0
Care Services
5.0
Activities
4.0
Staff
5.0
Meals & Dining
5.0

My Father Now Has a New Home And They Have Made Him Feel at Home

It is an excellent place to consider. I would recommend you talk to the community about your loved one. The community is able to requests special requests from the residents such as second helpings.

Anonymous

Independent Living

Toured community

June 2, 2021

4.0 out of 5 stars
Cleanliness
4.0
Friendliness
4.0
Value for Cost
4.0

Very clean facility with skilled living but no availability right now. Will be a talking point with family

Anonymous

Independent Living

Toured community

April 11, 2021

5.0 out of 5 stars
Cleanliness
5.0
Friendliness
5.0
Value for Cost
5.0

This is a facility that had standard one bedroom, one bath, and setting area at approx 550 sq ft. The director there was impressive and focused on creating a culture of service and comfort. Their pricing was the lowest of the three that we looked at and the facility was new. The nursing lead had good questions for us and exhibited a spirit of partnership that we are looking for. This facility is a strong contender.

Anonymous

Independent Living

Resident/client

September 28, 2020

5.0 out of 5 stars
Cleanliness
5.0
Friendliness
5.0
Value for Cost
5.0
Care Services
5.0
Activities
5.0

Great Place

We are very pleased with our place at the Reserve at Hamilton Trace. We received great help in locating this place from A Place For Mom.

Anonymous

Independent Living

Toured community

August 23, 2020

4.0 out of 5 stars
Cleanliness
4.0
Friendliness
4.0
Value for Cost
4.0

I adored the cottages. I think the use of space is perfect and the set up cute. The apt are alright. Not as new and as good of shape but I love the balacony.

Anonymous

Independent Living

Toured community

January 20, 2020

3.0 out of 5 stars
Cleanliness
3.0
Friendliness
3.0
Value for Cost
3.0

Could be interested in 3 bedroom cottage. [Name removed] and I visited The Reserve at Hamilton Trace and met with [name removed] on Fri. [date removed]. We were positively impressed and are definitely interested in this place. Unfortunately, they have no openings for cottages. We toured one of the 3 bedroom cottages (main floor with large finished basement) and it was way too big for our needs. Great location with LA Fitness across the street and only a few miles to the Fishers YMCA. There is no meal plan. Restaurant style dining appears reasonably priced and charges are added to monthly statement. I asked [name removed] about food cost and she said that for apartment dwellers, $400 per month is allocated for meals and rarely do those folks exceed the allotment.

Anonymous

Independent Living

Family/friend

April 24, 2019

0.5 out of 5 stars
Cleanliness
0.5
Friendliness
0.5
Value for Cost
0.5
Care Services
0.5
Activities
0.5

Terrible Memory Care facility

If you are looking for a Memory Care facility for your loved one, do not put them here. The staff is not trained for Alzheimer’s patients who are mobile. They don’t smile, they don’t engage with patients, the don’t redirect or re-approach. They put patients in front of the nurses station to sit all day so that they can text or socialize. If your loved one gets agitated, they call an ambulance to take them to the ER. They have no communication within departments. You have to tell them over and over again your loved ones needs. Please don’t place your loved ones at this facility.

Anonymous

Independent Living

Toured community

September 26, 2017

5.0 out of 5 stars
Cleanliness
5.0
Friendliness
5.0
Value for Cost
5.0

Very nice accommodations and pleasant surroundings. Efficient organization and friendly staff.

Anonymous

Independent Living

Toured community

May 23, 2017

5.0 out of 5 stars
Cleanliness
5.0
Friendliness
5.0
Value for Cost
5.0

I am unable to rate this place yet, however our choice was based on the room, location and amenities. We decided she should enjoy the independent living as long as she can.

Anonymous

Independent Living

Toured community

January 2, 2017

5.0 out of 5 stars
Cleanliness
5.0
Friendliness
5.0
Value for Cost
5.0

Beautiful facility with every amenity. Staff and residents could not have been nicer. The perfect fit for my 91 year mother!

Anonymous

Independent Living

Family/friend

November 16, 2016

4.0 out of 5 stars
Verified Review
Cleanliness
4.0
Friendliness
4.0
Value for Cost
4.0
Care Services
4.0
Activities
4.0

Accommodating Community

This has been a good transition for my mother with her move this community. She is doing quite well. I got most of my feedback from my sister who is close to her, I don't live in the same state. From what I heard so far everything is going well. We are comfortable with the care they are providing her with. There are plenty of activities for the residents. The management is very accommodating with my mother special needs. This is a good fit for her and her needs. Hopefully everything continues to go in a positive direction here at this community.

Anonymous

Independent Living

Toured community

July 26, 2016

4.0 out of 5 stars
Verified Review
Cleanliness
4.0
Friendliness
4.0
Value for Cost
4.0

Nice Looking Community

This is a lovely looking community. From what I saw everything looked very nice and well maintained. The staff was kind. They were informative and answered my questions. It is a nice community, but the location would not have work for the family.

Anonymous

Independent Living

Family/friend

July 14, 2016

5.0 out of 5 stars
Verified Review
Cleanliness
5.0
Friendliness
5.0
Value for Cost
5.0
Care Services
5.0
Activities
5.0

It Has Been Great

This is a new facility and everything is sparkling new, very sharp. My sister is living here and she likes the food it absolutely tasty and cooked properly. My sister finds several interests in the activities available. It has been good for her.

The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

Neighborhoods

See what the neighborhood has to offer and what’s nearby:
Map of the neighborhood around The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

Similar communities nearby

  • Find Assisted Living

  • Traditions at Solana community exterior

    Starting at$X,XXX/mo

    Traditions at Solana is a luxurious assisted living community located in beautiful and bustling Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana. Our waterfront community is located at Keystone at the Crossing, providing a park-like setting with abundant walking paths offering gorgeous views of the White...

  • Independence Village of Fishers South Community Exterior

    Starting at$X,XXX/mo

    Welcome to Independence Village of Fishers South! This isn’t just a place to reside — it’s a place where our community members truly shine, and we are glad to share this experience with them. Our various senior living options include enhanced living, assisted living, memory care, and respite...

  • Photo of Wyndmoor of Castleton

    Starting at$X,XXX/mo

    The Wyndmoor of Castleton (formerly Brookdale of Castleton - Managing Directors remain the same) is a licensed assisted living community in Indianapolis, Indiana. We are proud to be an award-winning community that showcases our commitment and dedication by providing our residents with outstanding...

  • Photo of The Barrington of Carmel a CCRC

    Starting at$X,XXX/mo

    Your new lifestyle can include security and a sense of wellbeing that comes from knowing that when you need care, it's right there. As Indianapolis' brand-new community, The Barrington of Carmel will offer state-of-the-art senior care capabilities, including a full array of services: assisted...

  • Photo of Five Star Residences of Clearwater

    Starting at$X,XXX/mo

    Located in the Clearwater area, Five Star Residences of Clearwater offers Independent and Assisted living with 81 licensed apartment from studios to two bedroom/ 2 bath apartments. Our campus also provides various floorplans of 7 Garden Homes. Enjoy unlimited dining services and complimentary...

  • Traditions at Brookside community entrance

    Starting at$X,XXX/mo

    Traditions at Brookside is a licensed senior retirement community with no large entry fee or endowment. Residents are served by providing superior, yet reasonably priced accommodations and services in a peaceful, quiet country atmosphere.Traditions at Brookside welcomes you with all of the peace...

  • Independence Village of Fishers East Lobby

    Starting at$X,XXX/mo

    Welcome to Independence Village of Fishers East! This isn’t just a place to reside — it’s a place where our community members truly shine, and we are glad to share this experience with them. Our various senior living options include independent living, assisted living, and memory care. Throughout...

The features and amenities that are displayed on this page contain marketing information provided by the community. A Place for Mom has not confirmed the completeness of the provided information, and cannot guarantee its accuracy. If you become aware of any information that should be updated or noted, please contact A Place for Mom. A Place for Mom uses the term “assisted living” to indicate that the community provides some level of assistance with daily living activities. It does not indicate that the facility meets official state requirements for level of care.

Back to top