4089 Nesconset Highway, South Setauket, NY 11720
Anonymous
Child of resident/client
Overall a wonderful community
Everyone there has been wonderful. My mother-in-law is very happy. She just wishes there was more activities that she was interested in. Doesn't seem to be a lot going on. But she's very comfortable and the staff is really nice and she's made some nice friends. She has a room with an exterior door, so she's very happy with its location and with the ability to step outside into the seating areas.
Read all reviewsAtria South Setauket
Atria South Setauket sets a new standard for senior living. From exquisite grounds to elegant interiors, our spaces illuminate your life in relaxed luxury. Located in South Setauket, New York, Atria South Setauket is in convenient reach of all the great local attractions and leisure opportunities our distinguished city has to offer — like Benner's Farm, East Setauket Pond Park, Gallery North, and more. And, we always offer residents the opportunities to explore our great city with family and loved ones.
Atria South Setauket supports older adults with our independent and supportive lifestyle options. Our all-inclusive rate includes staff on site, 24 hours a day, supportive services, engaging events, healthy meals, and essential utilities. Supportive living residents are ensured top-of-the-line care from our exceptional caregiving staff, who collaborate with individual residents to establish personalized plans that meet their unique needs and lifestyle goals. Let us know what you need at Atria South Setauket today!
With an array of activities and fun opportunities to have at any time, there’s never a dull moment at Atria South Setauket. Whether it’s relaxing on the patio, swimming in the outdoor pool, or taking a cooking class with friends, residents enjoy hallmark activities...
Learn more about the Best of Senior Living awards and this year’s winners.
See all 2026 award winnersAtria South Setauket
Total monthly costs depend on room type, select services, and the level of care needed
Contact a local advisorGet a quote from your local advisor*Prices quoted are monthly rental charges and are provided by the communities themselves. Actual prices may differ due to one-time fees, timing and care services required. Speak with your Senior Living Advisor to learn more.
A Place for Mom has scored Atria South Setauket with 9.4 out of 10 using our proprietary review score based on 8 reviews in the last 2 years. Over all time, Atria South Setauket has 100 reviews with an average "overall experience" of 4.1 out of 5.
Anonymous
Assisted LivingFamily/friend
August 20, 2025
Everyone there has been wonderful. My mother-in-law is very happy. She just wishes there was more activities that she was interested in. Doesn't seem to be a lot going on. But she's very comfortable and the staff is really nice and she's made some nice friends. She has a room with an exterior door, so she's very happy with its location and with the ability to step outside into the seating areas.
JaymeSue M
Independent LivingFamily/friend
May 13, 2025
[name removed] was incredible! We were having issues trying to convince my brother in-law that he needed to be in a place with more people around. He can be ornery. [name removed] exhibited the patience of a saint with him! I so appreciate her!
Jenn
Independent LivingFamily/friend
April 22, 2025
The Village South Setauket is awesome. While the facility has some cosmetic needs (it's an older building, but they are doing upgrades one area at a time), the staff could not be more lovely. My dad has been showered with attention, being called by name everywhere he goes. There are a wide variety of activities, with a daily schedule that rotates enough to stay interesting. Rent includes breakfast, dinner, and a light lunch. The location itself is great, across the street from restaurants and shops, and the Village provides rides to shopping trips. I highly recommend this facility for the value, the incredible staff, and the well-rounded experience.
Anonymous
Assisted LivingFamily/friend
March 24, 2025
The people at the facility are professional, and when you request something, they usually act immediately.
Anonymous
Assisted LivingFamily/friend
March 11, 2025
It wasn't all they promised. The car service is nonexistent. The activities are usually the same. I think my dad is happy with them.
Jenn P
Independent LivingFamily/friend
December 17, 2024
I visited multiple facilities in search for a place for my dad who was moving cross-country to be near his grandchildren. From the moment I called, the staff at The Village at South Setauket were warm, friendly, and welcoming. I met a variety of folks on my tour, and each one had worked there for no fewer than 7 years. It is clear that the staff is supported and supportive, and they work together as a team to ensure that the residents and their families are loved as if they were their own. I cannot say enough kind words about The Village at South Setauket. The living space, the food, the activities are all wonderful, but the staff is what really makes this place a home for my dad.
Veronica D
Assisted LivingFamily/friend
November 27, 2024
I am very pleased with the way the staff are attentive and take care of the residents. My mother really likes living there. I think they can have just a little bit more activities. Other than that, really love it.
Anonymous
Independent LivingFamily/friend
November 14, 2024
The aids were lovely. The staff was attentive. The choice of daily movie was random. They could try to offer some more that appeal to the mostly older women who live there.
Anonymous
Independent LivingFamily/friend
October 1, 2024
What we like the most about Atria South is the staff, the location and the safety. Yes, I would recommend this community to other families, but the facility was sold, so I am nervous about any changes moving forward
Susan M
Independent LivingFamily/friend
August 26, 2024
It is more affordable than the other Atrias. It needs some improvement on the outside and maybe some updating inside. That being said, my mother's studio was freshly painted and new carpeting was installed. The staff is helpful and caring. The common areas are clean. The outside in the back is pretty with a pool.
Anonymous
Assisted LivingFamily/friend
July 17, 2024
Thus far my aunt [name removed] seems content. The food is good, the room is clean and cared for by Staff. Love that bingo is Daily as she likes card games. The Medtech staff is also nice and kind, the Front desk receptionists Are all kind, helpful, cheerful-
Anonymous
Assisted LivingFamily/friend
June 19, 2024
The Atria has gotten so bad that I had to move my mother from this facility . The cleanliness , food and care are horrible . Activities shown on calendar almost always canceled or when my mom showed up no one was there to do the class/activity. There is a resident across the hallway from my mom who smokes so much the hallway is so smelly from smoke they had to put a air purifier in the hall it was plugged into the wall and a tripping hazard.
Anonymous
Assisted LivingResident/client
May 29, 2024
It's a good place.
Jessica
Independent LivingFamily/friend
May 21, 2024
I think my dad is doing very well and very happy but my life is really chaotic and other than occasional text. I'm in so little communication with him. I would not have any details at all about the Atria, but I absolutely with confidence could say no news is good news like he's totally happy there and his wonderful as it seemed when I was there and touring and setting him up it still is. He does rave about individual moments and things they do there etc. etc. the few times I speak to him. I actually highly recommend them. They are exactly what they say they are :-) it's a converted older hotel versus the purpose built Atria that's nearby. That's more like a country club but significantly more expensive? I feel like management and the people they hire is exceptional? The vibe there was genuinely compassionate, caring detail oriented on their game. Again, it's funky. The dining room is basically in the basement and you have to walk down along Hall to quote the other side because there's independent living on the left where my dad is and Assisted Living on the right so it's like two sections? But there's a separate dining room on the floor above For, the Assisted Living but because the way the kitchen is set up, that's the side that also has the dining room in sense for the independent. Again, pretty unusual a typical but considering the budget value to be there, it's really a gem and a find.
Anonymous
Assisted LivingFamily/friend
May 14, 2024
My dad is currently a resident at Atria South Setauket and everything has been great for him so far. He is very happy at this facility. I would recommend Atria South Setauket to others who are looking for an Assisted Living Facility.
Mary
Assisted LivingFamily/friend
November 3, 2023
The people are wonderful, it is inclusive and they make everyone feel welcome and at home. We picked this community because of the staff, activites and location.
Anonymous
Independent LivingFamily/friend
November 1, 2023
My loved one is currently a resident at Atria South Setauket. I've had good experiences with all of the staff that I've interacted with, except for one. My loved one's room is always clean, bed is made and bathroom tidy when I'm there. The laundry is done once a week. They communicate with me when necessary and check in when they see me there for a visit. The move in was very smooth on their end. They let us start moving stuff in a week before my loved one moved in. I would and have recommended Atria South Setauket to others.
Anonymous
Assisted LivingResident/client
September 25, 2023
I picked this community because of the affordability. The experience with the community, has been friendly.
Anonymous
Assisted LivingToured community
July 26, 2023
We toured Atria South Setauket when searching for an Assisted Living facility for our loved one. This facility was not all inclusive like some of the other facilities that we looked at. I also didn't like the basement apartments.
Anonymous
Assisted LivingFamily/friend
June 20, 2023
I made the mistake in thinking that Assisted Living helped with dementia people but unfortunately my mom only stayed at Atria for 4 months. We needs a "Memory Care" facility and they didn't have it. I wish I knew so she could've transitioned. I had to move her to another facility. The people were nice and the food was very good. I would recommend Atria South Setauket, I was however very disappointed that they didn't at least give me half my money back when I signed on. I think they should give you 6 months of living there. Grace period. They do require a $[removed] sign up fee.
Atria South Setauket
Find Assisted Living
Starting at$X,XXX/mo
Starting at$2,416+ monthly
A non-profit Continuing Care Retirement Community, Jefferson’s Ferry’s residents fully enjoy retirement without worrying about market swings, future health care needs, chores or maintenance. Sponsored by the Mather/St. Charles Health Alliance, Jefferson’s Ferry boasts three levels of living: 248...
Starting at$X,XXX/mo
Starting at$4,900+ monthly
The Bristal at Lake Grove is a lovely assisted living community, situated just minutes from Long Island's historic Three Village Area. This is our third Suffolk County assisted living residence. Like all communities of The Bristal Assisted Living, the senior care that residents will experience...
Starting at$X,XXX/mo
Starting at$4,800+ monthly
The Bristal Assisted Living offers incomparable care, the finest luxury amenities, a packed activity calendar and so much more. Call today to schedule your visit.
Starting at$X,XXX/mo
Starting at$5,295+ monthly
As one of the most trusted senior living providers on Long Island, Atria East Northport has served families like yours for more than 25 years. With a continued commitment to quality, they have just completed a full-scale renovation to enhance the beauty and functionality of the community — and...
Starting at$X,XXX/mo
Starting at$3,530+ monthly
UNDER CONSTRUCTION FOR COMPLETION IN 2020Located in Yaphank, Long Island, New York, The Chelsea At Brookhaven offers personalized Assisted Living in studio and one-bedroom apartments. Our Country Cottage provides a safe, pleasant, and supportive environment for residents with Alzheimer’s and...
Starting at$X,XXX/mo
Starting at$5,100+ monthly
Gurwin Jewish provides a menu of options all on one campus. Gurwin pride shines through in all we do. Assisted Living by Gurwin: At Gurwin Jewish~ Fay J. Lindner Residences, you can have it all: the ultimate in luxurious assisted living in an environment that embraces the traditions of Jewish...
Starting at$X,XXX/mo
Starting at$4,000+ monthly
Birchwood Suites is a a fully enhanced assisted living community nestled on five acres of beautiful property in East Northport, NY. Our community offers a variety of luxury suites when life becomes too difficult or unsafe to live alone. Our Enhanced License, appointed by the New York State...
The features and amenities that are displayed on this page contain marketing information provided by the community. A Place for Mom has not confirmed the completeness of the provided information, and cannot guarantee its accuracy. If you become aware of any information that should be updated or noted, please contact A Place for Mom. A Place for Mom uses the term “assisted living” to indicate that the community provides some level of assistance with daily living activities. It does not indicate that the facility meets official state requirements for level of care.
